
Four Tales of Prehistoric Horror
by H.J. Dutton

Prehistory is rare in horror fiction. The list below was a headache to compile because I couldn’t find many examples of prehistoric horror of the non-dino variety. The prevalence of dinosaurs above other ancient beasties in fiction has roots in the likes of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s The Lost World (1912).
However, dino popularity today likely stems from Michael Crichton’s Jurassic Park (1990) and, of course, Steven Spielberg’s 1993 screen adaptation. While Crichton’s novel isn’t technically horror, compared to Spielberg’s vision, it’s far more grisly. For example, the infamous Dilophosaurus – the frilled, acid-spitting dino in the film – is more anatomically accurate in the book and disembowels Nedry in explicit detail. Even more intense is the book’s prologue, in which a number of Procompsognathus arrive on the Costa Rican mainland where they prey on human infants (3-8).
Less common than tales with out-of-context dinosaurs are horror stories set in prehistoric times, of which I could find only one prose fiction example. The most familiar example is probably the recent UK film Out of Darkness (2022), about a band of early humans in the Stone Age (they speak a fictitious early language) who think a supernatural entity is hunting them.
Prehistory appears much more frequently in the realms of cosmic horror. Prehistorical artifacts and entities illustrate a timescale in which human civilization seems small and fleeting. Six thousand years, an age for humanity that might seem ancient, is in fact less than a blip in Earth’s timeline. Weaving this sobering reality into cosmic horror fiction makes it more poignant. Laird Barron’s “Old Virginia,” for example, explores the concept of beings who have guided and manipulated sentient life on Earth since its very dawn: “The dinosaurs couldn’t do it in a hundred million years. Nor the sharks in their oceans three times that. The monkeys showed promise, but never realized their potential. Humans are the best pawns so far – the ones with a passion for fire and mystery. With subtle guidance they – you – can return this world to the paradise it was when the ice was thick and the sun dim (17).”
Below I’ve compiled three classic examples and one fairly recent example horror fiction with prehistoric elements.

“The Terror of Blue John Gap” – Arthur Conan Doyle (1910)
During his stay at a farm, Dr. James Hardcastle hears rumors of an ancient Roman mineshaft located near the property. His curiosity urges him to explore. Unbeknownst to him, however, the mine is far from empty.
“Children of the Kingdom” – T.E.D. Klein (1980)
Set before and during NYC’s 1977 blackout, the story follows an anonymous narrator as he moves his grandfather into an assisted living facility. During one of his visits, a city-wide power outage strikes. Amid the ensuing chaos, something ancient rises from below the city’s streets to terrorize its citizens.
“Strata” – Edward Bryant (1980)
Employees working for a fossil fuel mining company in Wyoming report encountering aggressive apparitions while at the job site. But these aren’t your average specters. These are something far stronger – and older.
“Basic Shade” – Josh Malerman (2018)
In prehistoric times, a pair of hominids notice new illustrations on the walls of the cave they inhabit. Artwork neither of them created. What transpires can be described as the first haunting in human history.
Cosmic Horror from Horrific Scribblings that Transcends History:
The Middle Reaches by L. Andrew Cooper
This weird dark fantasy/horror epic centers around a dangerous in-between realm and the characters drawn to it, characters who enter a cosmic struggle that began before the dawn of humanity. Across its four books, Cooper covers the full spectrum of weird and cosmic horror, from multiversal chaos to Chambers/Lovecraft tie-ins such as the King in Yellow and Carcosa.
For more prehistoric horror mixed with twisted timelines and cosmic catastrophes, consider the following from Horrific Scribes:

Read Raymond Brunell‘s short story “We Have Not Died Yet” in Horrific Scribes October 2025.
Description: An archaeologist excavating a tar pit discovers impossibly preserved remains—human bodies from eight hundred years in the future, all frozen mid-run, fleeing something. When she recognizes her daughter’s dental work in one of the skulls, she realizes the pit doesn’t just preserve the future-dead: it’s already claiming them. This is a story about temporal paradox, the futility of warnings, and what it means to see your child’s corpse before she’s born.

Read James Edward O’Brien’s short story “The Reef Ship Geraldo” in Horrific Scribes October 2026.
Description: The crew of a salvage vessel follow an otherworldly siren’s call emanating from a polluted reef in a dead sea.

Read Jim Best‘s short story “Dead or Alive” in Horrific Scribes October 2025.
Description: In the back country of the Mexican desert, two gringo outlaws on the run from a bank heist encounter an otherworldly horror.

Read J.W. Bodden‘s short story “Twink Death” in Horrific Scribes September 2026.
Description: Holliday enjoys the easy hustler’s life on the Strip. But as his clients dwindle and age erases his twink figure, he has to make a hard choice. Holliday decides to seek out the Fancy Man. The legendary pimp rules the Strip as a god. He is the only one who can release him from the curse of Twink Death.

Read Marisa McAdams‘s short story “To You It Shall Be for Meat” in Horrific Scribes March 2026.
Description: A serial cheater and his family are haunted not by ghosts, but by the house itself.

Read Christine Lajewski‘s story “Mother’s Milk” in Horrific Scribes March 2026.
Description: A goddess got displaced and demoted. Then she got mad.
Sources
Barron, Laird. The Imago Sequence and Other Stories. Night Shade Books, 2009.
Crichton, Michael. “Prologue: The Bite of the Raptor.” Jurassic Park, Alfred A. Knopf, New York City, NY, 1990, pp. 3–8.






Leave a Reply